Americans expressed greater confidence in the fairness of the November 3, 2026, midterm elections after voting ended, but substantial differences remain between political parties. A new University of California San Diego survey found that 66% of Americans considered the elections free and fair, compared with 49% who expected a fair election in September. Republican confidence remained considerably lower than confidence among Democrats and independent voters.
The findings, released November 20, provide a detailed look at how Americans responded to an election in which Democrats won control of both chambers of Congress. Although confidence increased nationally, the improvement was concentrated among Democrats and independents. Republican attitudes changed relatively little from levels recorded before Election Day.
President Donald Trump initially accepted his party's losses before later questioning the legitimacy of the results. However, researchers found that skepticism among Republican voters was already widespread before those comments.
Republican Confidence Changes Modestly After Election
The UC San Diego Center for Transparent and Trusted Elections surveyed 3,430 American adults between November 9 and November 16. Participants had previously responded to a September survey, allowing researchers to compare attitudes before and after the election.
Among Republicans, 52% expressed confidence that votes nationwide were counted as voters intended. That represented a decrease from 58% in September, a six-percentage-point change.
A separate question produced somewhat different results. When asked whether the midterms were free and fair, 46% of Republicans answered yes, compared with 55% who had expected a fair election before voting began.
The distinction matters because confidence in accurate vote counting is not identical to confidence in the overall fairness of an election. People may have concerns about campaign activities, election administration, misinformation, or other issues without necessarily believing that ballots were counted incorrectly.
The researchers also observed that Republicans entered the election with relatively low confidence. Their findings suggest that the smaller post-election change may partly reflect attitudes that were already established.
Democrats and Independents Report Growing Trust
Democrats showed a much larger shift in their attitudes toward the election. Before November 3, only 55% expected the midterms to be free and fair. Afterward, 93% said the election had met that standard.
Independent voters showed a similar change, although their confidence remained lower than that of Democrats. Their belief that the election was free and fair increased from 43% before voting to 66% afterward.
Confidence in accurate vote counting also increased among both groups. Following the election, 92% of Democrats and 69% of independents expressed confidence that votes nationwide were counted as intended.
These findings reflect a familiar pattern in American politics. Supporters of parties that win elections often become more confident in election administration, while supporters of losing parties may become less confident.
Lauren Prather, co-director of the university's election research center, said the relatively modest Republican decline was noteworthy because Democrats and independents reported much larger improvements.
She suggested that circumstances surrounding an election, including the way political leaders communicate results, can influence public confidence alongside the election outcome itself.
Trust Has Shifted Since the 2024 Presidential Election
The latest survey also provides context for changes in Republican confidence since Trump's presidential victory in November 2024.
Following that election, more than 80% of Republicans expressed confidence in the national vote count. By November 2026, the figure had fallen to 52%, representing a decline of approximately 30 percentage points.
However, those numbers do not establish that Republicans changed their opinions specifically because of Trump's recent statements. The surveys measured confidence in elections, not whether respondents supported the president or why individual voters distrusted the process.
The researchers found that overall national confidence had also declined before the midterms. In January 2026, 60% of Americans trusted that votes would be counted accurately nationwide. By September, that figure had fallen to 55%.
Following the midterms, overall confidence in accurate vote counting increased to 69%.
The pattern demonstrates how election confidence can change substantially over time. It also shows why comparing opinions immediately after different elections requires attention to the political circumstances surrounding each vote.
Trump Initially Accepted Results Before Raising Questions
Trump's public response to the midterm results received considerable attention because of his past disputes over election outcomes.
On election night, he told Fox News interviewer Bret Baier that he would accept the results as Democrats gained seats in Congress. His initial response differed from his repeated challenges to the outcome of the 2020 presidential election.
Several prominent Republican candidates who lost their races also acknowledged their defeats. Election researchers identified those concessions, along with decisive margins and relatively few reported disruptions, as possible contributors to greater public confidence.
Days later, Trump questioned the fairness of the election in a social media post. His comments renewed discussion about election integrity among political observers and members of both parties.
The survey does not establish how many Republicans agreed with his later remarks. It also does not determine whether Republican skepticism came primarily from Trump supporters, voters critical of Trump, or people with broader concerns about election administration.
Those distinctions are important when interpreting the results. Distrust in a voting process does not automatically indicate support for a particular politician or acceptance of a specific allegation.
Americans Disagree About Election Fraud Discussions
The researchers also asked respondents whether political leaders were spending too much or too little time discussing potential voter fraud.
Among Republicans, 35% believed politicians were discussing the issue too little, while 37% considered the amount of discussion appropriate. Only 15% believed political leaders were discussing fraud too much.
Democrats expressed considerably different opinions. A majority, 56%, said politicians were devoting too much attention to potential voter fraud, compared with 7% who wanted more discussion.
Independent voters were more likely to believe politicians discussed voter fraud too much than too little.
These differences reveal competing expectations about how political leaders should address election security. Some voters want greater scrutiny and public discussion, while others worry that repeated allegations can weaken confidence without sufficient supporting evidence.
The survey measured public opinions about fraud discussions. It did not establish that widespread fraud occurred in the 2026 elections.
Voters Agree on State and Local Election Control
Despite their differences over election confidence, Americans showed considerable agreement on who should administer elections.
The survey found that 62% favored keeping primary responsibility with state and local officials, while 18% preferred greater federal control. Support for local administration crossed party lines.
This finding is significant because American elections are administered through thousands of state and local jurisdictions. Election officials oversee voter registration, polling locations, ballot processing, and vote counting under applicable laws.
The researchers also found widespread concern about misleading political content generated by artificial intelligence. Strong majorities across political affiliations worried that fabricated audio or video could influence elections.
Another area of agreement involved prediction markets, where participants can place financial bets on political outcomes. More than 70% across the three major political groups supported restrictions preventing election officials and workers from participating in those markets.
These results suggest that shared concerns about election administration remain even when voters disagree about the fairness of particular election outcomes.
Researchers Plan to Continue Studying Election Trust
UC San Diego researchers intend to continue tracking how Americans evaluate elections and whether confidence changes between voting cycles.
The center is working with election officials in several states to examine approaches for strengthening public understanding. Those efforts include greater transparency, educational programs, and opportunities for residents to observe how election systems operate.
The November survey carries an overall margin of error of plus or minus 1.7 percentage points. Like other public opinion surveys, its results represent estimates of broader public attitudes rather than exact measurements of every voter's beliefs.
The findings show both an improvement in national election confidence and a continuing difference between political groups. They do not identify a single explanation for Republican skepticism or demonstrate that one political leader caused it.
Researchers will continue examining whether the increase in confidence among Democrats and independents persists and whether public trust can become more consistent regardless of which party wins future elections.
